 (2).webp)
Welcoming pets into a rental isn’t just about being nice—it’s about making smart business decisions. In pet-loving communities like Gilbert, AZ, properties that don’t allow animals risk getting passed over by a growing segment of renters. But with the right structure, a pet-friendly rental can actually improve tenant retention and your bottom line. The key is to create boundaries through policies that protect your investment and ensure everyone—two-legged and four-legged—can coexist peacefully. If you're wondering where to start, explore these Gilbert-specific accidental landlord tips to build a foundation for success.
Key Takeaways
- Pet-friendly rentals appeal to a broader tenant base in Gilbert and increase lease longevity
- Charging pet rent, deposits, and fees offsets wear and tear expenses
- A detailed lease addendum is essential for regulating pet behavior and expectations
- Landlords must comply with Arizona laws regarding service and emotional support animals
- Screening both the tenant and the pet prevents most property-related problems
Why Gilbert Renters Prefer Pet-Friendly Homes
Pet ownership is on the rise in Arizona, and Gilbert is no exception. With an abundance of parks, walking trails, and dog-welcoming patios, residents increasingly seek rentals that welcome their furry companions. Tenants with pets are often more stable and less likely to relocate frequently due to the limited availability of pet-friendly housing. That means fewer turnover costs and more consistent income for landlords.
Structuring Pet Fees to Balance Risk and Return
Allowing pets doesn’t mean opening the door to risk. When structured correctly, pet-related charges can both protect your property and boost revenue. Here's how:
Common Fee Options:
- Monthly Pet Rent: An additional $25–$50 per pet is standard in many Gilbert rentals.
- Non-Refundable Pet Fee: Helps cover deep cleaning and initial administrative costs.
- Refundable Pet Deposit: Returned if no damage is present at move-out.
Clear communication is essential. Break down which fees are refundable, which are not, and how they’re applied. Aligning these terms with your overall lease and security deposit policies provides a strong legal foundation and prevents disputes later.
Preparing Your Property for Pet Tenants
Making your rental pet-friendly doesn’t require a complete overhaul—but a few smart upgrades can go a long way toward minimizing damage.
Recommended Enhancements:
- Pet-Proof Flooring: Opt for tile, vinyl plank, or sealed hardwood over carpeting
- Washable Wall Finishes: Use satin or semi-gloss paint that resists scuffs and stains
- Secure Window Coverings: Choose blinds or curtains that won’t be destroyed by curious pets
- Enclosed Outdoor Spaces: Fencing in yards or patios adds appeal and safety
- Waste Stations: If you manage a multi-unit property, offering designated cleanup areas encourages responsible pet ownership
These improvements not only reduce repair costs but can also increase tenant satisfaction—an essential element in long-term lease agreements.
Crafting a Pet Addendum That Sets Expectations
A strong lease should always include a detailed pet addendum. This document goes beyond just saying pets are allowed—it sets expectations and enforces accountability.
What to Include:
- Pet Approval Process: List allowed species, breed or weight restrictions, and required documentation (vaccines, licenses, etc.)
- Fee and Deposit Breakdown: Specify amounts and refund conditions
- Behavior Guidelines: Address leash rules, noise, waste disposal, and property damage
- Violation Consequences: Outline potential fines, damage liability, or lease termination scenarios
This level of clarity removes guesswork for tenants and empowers you to enforce the rules fairly.
Understanding the Legal Distinction: Pets vs. Support Animals
In Arizona—and under federal law—there’s a big difference between a pet and a service or emotional support animal (ESA). Failing to understand that distinction can open the door to Fair Housing complaints.
What Landlords Must Know:
- No Pet Fees for Service/Support Animals: These are considered medical aids, not pets
- Verification Rights: You can request documentation for ESAs, but not for service animals
- Behavior Still Matters: You can enforce cleanliness and safety rules regardless of the animal’s classification
- You Cannot Deny Housing Based on Disability: A legitimate ESA or service animal request must be honored, provided it meets basic standards of behavior
Understanding the legal line is essential. When in doubt, consult legal counsel or a property management expert before denying a pet or charging extra.
Keep an Eye on the Property with Regular Inspections
Even the best-behaved pets can cause unintentional damage over time. The key to preventing long-term issues is staying proactive with regular checkups.
Best Practices:
- Quarterly or Biannual Inspections: These catch small problems early
- Pet-Specific Checklists: Look for chew marks, odors, scratches, and staining
- Document Everything: Use photos and notes to create a clear timeline of any issues
- Compare Move-In/Out Reports: Track condition changes over time
Not only does this safeguard your property, it also shows tenants that you’re engaged and care about maintaining standards.
Double Screening: Know the Tenant, Know the Pet
You already screen tenants for financial and criminal history—but what about their pets? A little due diligence here can save a lot of headaches.
Pet Screening Tips:
- Request breed, age, weight, and temperament information
- Collect up-to-date vaccination and flea/tick treatment records
- Ask for references from prior landlords (especially regarding pet behavior)
- Consider requesting a short pet video or an in-person meet-and-greet
This additional layer of screening ensures that pets fit your property and won’t pose unnecessary risks to neighbors or the home itself.
Dealing with Unauthorized Pets
No matter how clear your policy is, some tenants may still try to sneak in pets. Quick and consistent action is necessary.
Steps to Take:
- Issue a Lease Violation Notice
- Schedule an Inspection to Confirm
- Offer a Compliance Path (i.e., add the pet legally, pay the fees)
- Enforce Penalties or Eviction if Needed
Enforcing your pet policy early keeps your authority intact and sends a strong message about expectations.
Pet-Friendly Doesn’t Mean Policy-Free
Allowing pets in your Gilbert rental can be a smart move—but only with a solid structure in place. From a thorough lease addendum to proactive inspections, the details matter. You’ll also want a system to handle maintenance efficiently, especially since wear and tear can increase with animals in the home. Our guide on the ultimate rental maintenance plan is a great place to start if you want to keep your property in top shape.
Build Long-Term Value with the Right Pet Policy Strategy
Renting to pet owners isn’t a liability—it’s a calculated opportunity when backed by a smart strategy. At PMI PHX Gateway, we help Gilbert landlords turn pet-friendly housing into profitable, low-risk investments through customized leasing, inspections, and tenant screening systems. If you’re ready to take a structured approach that still appeals to today’s tenants, speak with our tenant screening experts and learn how we protect your property while maximizing your returns.
FAQs
Q1: Can I limit the number or size of pets in my Gilbert rental?
Yes, as a landlord, you can set reasonable limits on the number, size, or breed of pets, as long as they don’t conflict with Fair Housing laws.
Q2: Are emotional support animals considered pets in Arizona?
No. Emotional support animals are not considered pets and are legally protected. You cannot charge fees for them or deny housing due to their presence.
Q3: What happens if a tenant’s pet causes damage?
If covered in your lease and pet addendum, you may deduct repair costs from the pet deposit or hold the tenant liable for damages beyond normal wear.
Q4: Should I allow exotic pets in my rental?
That’s up to you, but it’s common to restrict exotic animals due to higher risks. Clearly outline what's allowed in your pet policy.
Q5: How do I know if a tenant is lying about a pet being a service animal?
You may request ESA documentation, but you cannot ask for proof for service animals. However, you can still enforce rules around safety and cleanliness.
